As the offseason kicks into high gear, the New York Mets find themselves at a crossroads, with several key decisions looming that could reshape their roster for 2026. But here’s where it gets controversial: while all eyes are on Pete Alonso’s potential return, there’s a quieter, yet equally significant, exodus of eight players who likely won’t be back in Queens next season. And this is the part most people miss—these departures could dramatically alter the team’s dynamics, for better or worse.
The Mets’ offseason hinges on Alonso’s decision. The powerhouse first baseman has opted out of his $24 million contract, seeking a multi-year deal on the open market. If he re-signs, it’s a massive win for the Mets, allowing them to refocus on pitching and defense as they aim to rebound from a disappointing 2025. But if he walks, the Mets face a double challenge: replacing his bat and retooling their roster across the board.
Meanwhile, eight players who finished the 2025 season on the Mets’ 40-man roster are now free agents, and their futures with the team look uncertain at best. Let’s break down who they are and why their departures could be a turning point for the franchise:
- RHP Griffin Canning: A midseason success story with a 3.77 ERA over 16 starts, Canning’s season was cut short by an Achilles injury. Will the Mets gamble on his recovery, or is the risk too high?
- RHP Ryan Helsley: Acquired as a closer, Helsley’s 7.20 ERA in New York was a far cry from his stellar 3.00 ERA in St. Louis. Could he bounce back if given another chance, or is his Mets tenure over?
- OF Starling Marte: A fan favorite since 2022, Marte’s peak seems behind him. With injury concerns and age catching up, is his leadership worth keeping, or will the Mets prioritize younger talent?
- OF Cedric Mullins: Traded from Baltimore, Mullins struggled with a .182 average and subpar defense. Will another team take a chance on him, or is his stock too low?
- RHP Tyler Rogers: Despite a higher ERA with the Mets (2.30) compared to the Giants (1.80), Rogers’ unique sidearm delivery makes him a tempting bullpen option. But is his style enough to overcome his recent struggles?
- LHP Gregory Soto: A deadline acquisition with a 4.50 ERA in New York, Soto’s numbers suggest bad luck rather than poor performance. Could he be a hidden gem, or is his time with the Mets over?
- RHP Ryne Stanek: Leading the team with 65 bullpen appearances, Stanek’s 5.47 ERA raises questions. Will the Mets bring him back, or is it time to move on?
- DH Jesse Winker: Plagued by injuries, Winker showed flashes of brilliance but wasn’t consistent. With the Mets seeking an upgrade at DH, is his time in Queens up?
Here’s the controversial part: While most of these players underperformed, some—like Rogers and Soto—could still have value. Should the Mets take a chance on them, or is it better to cut ties and start fresh? And what does this say about the team’s strategy moving forward? Are they prioritizing immediate wins or building for the long term?
As the Mets navigate this offseason, one thing is clear: the decisions they make now will define their 2026 season. But what do you think? Should they bring back any of these players, or is a complete overhaul in order? Let us know in the comments—this debate is far from over.
